Wednesday, September 16, 2009

“What is history but a fable agreed upon”

Theory Of Knowledge
“What is history but a fable agreed upon”
Did Hitler really kill himself? Was Gandhi really the most important piece in the jigsaw of India’s independence struggle? Are Nostradamus's prophecies really proven to be accurate in our history? Did the USA in reality have no idea about the Pearl Harbor attacks?
The precise answer to all these questions will in all likelihood always remain elusive to mankind. This is because there is no way foolproof method through which we can determine what really happened in our past. Maybe all the incidents that we do study in our textbooks are true. But we cannot be naïve enough to believe everything we study through these so-called “history” textbooks blindly. History is just like the passing of stories through the generations, either orally or in written accounts. But while it was passed from one generation to the next, it is inevitable that parts of these ‘stories’ may have been modified to suit the concerned parties. And since we have no other alternative than to believe these stories about crucial incidents in the past, we accept them as our history. Through out my school years, I always had reservations about the accuracy of all the incidents we studied in history. The authoritative tone adopted by these books only fueled my reservations. I just wondered that how could somebody recollect and retell tales of the past with such authority and command without any mention of evidences that would prove the same. For instance, “history” tells us that Gandhi tried hard to maintain the unity of India, is there any evidence to prove the same. But even he could have the desire to split the country into two (not necessarily a bad desire!) but just dint show the same and rather worked on it through a series of backroom dealings. These thoughts are ofcourse mere speculation with no concrete evidence, but we can see just how easy it is to manipulate what really happened in the past. Anyone with the authority and power can modify history to suit his/her propaganda and personal interests. A classic example of these ‘propaganda wars’ is the treatment of the issues of communism and capitalism in the history textbooks of the east and the west in the mid 1950s. While, the textbooks in Russia spoke of capitalism as the system for the rich, who had caused slavery and the massive differences in the standards of living between the rich and the poor in the west, it never mentioned anything about the evils of communism – Economic stagnation and government oppressions. Thus as a result the students grew up knowing only how Russia evaded the economic depression of 1929 through its communist structure but did not know anything about the large scale corruption and consumer slavery prevalent in Russia. The American textbooks too were biased to a similar extent. But in midst of all this, the world as a whole was deprived of the real truth. This case is true for almost every incident in history as textbook publishers’ main aim is profits and hence would not risk the government’s censure by going against the prevalent norm of the recollection of historical events. I hence agree completely with Bonaparte’s statement that history is merely a fable agreed upon

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

KOW SOURCES: REPORT TO DETAIL ALLEGED ABUSE INSIDE CIA SECRET PRISONS

SOURCES: REPORT TO DETAIL ALLEGED ABUSE INSIDE CIA SECRET PRISONS
The article comments about the unethical interrogation techniques of the CIA officials with respect to Al Qaeda prisoners. After the September 11 attacks, the treatment meted out to terrorist suspects has been made drastically stringent and in some cases inhuman. While there is no mention of the unethical nature of illegal interrogation techniques, a knower can perceive from the tone of the article that the author is reprimanding the CIA for using such severe methods to extract the truth from terrorist suspects. The neutral tone is compromised to convey the content of the article.
The author of the article cites an unnamed source that has access to a classified report of the probe on CIA interrogations. The author seems to share his source’s perception that the CIA officers are indeed guilty of using illegal interrogation techniques on terrorist suspects in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. That is the primary knowledge issue of the article. The knower (reader) can perceive that emotions are running high in the mindset of the author as he sympathizes with the prisoners. The article isn’t completely objective or neutral enough to help the reader to come to a knowledgeable and logical conclusion. For instance there is no concrete perspective in the article of the CIA officials with only a inconclusive remark by a spokesperson finding its way in the article. Without the CIA point of view about the interrogations, we cannot comment upon the ethical nature of such events. While the article primarily deals with the report about prosecuting CIA officials guilty of using such illegal interrogation techniques, we must concentrate on the macrocosmic issue of justifying the ethical nature of these interrogation practices. Though the article does not clearly mention the ethics issue, it is very clearly prevalent in the argument due to the language used. Can we really reason out using inhuman means to extract the truth from terrorist suspects? This could after all help in saving thousands of innocent lives by preventing such future incidents. But is inhuman treatment of terrorists the real answer. There are two points to reason before coming to a logical conclusion. Firstly, we must not forget that these prisoners are “suspected terrorists” and are not yet convicted of their crimes. One does not need to go back to far in history to validate the above statement. Mohammad Hafeez, the Indian doctor too was suspected of being a terrorist for a period of 4 months by the entire planet, only to be late proved innocent. They may just be ordinary innocent people. One can just imagine the state of one individual who may be a victim of circumstances and still be forced to undergo such severe interrogation practices. Secondly, even if these prisoners are confirmed terrorists, their jobs are most likely already done and we know enough about the Al Qaeda modus operandi to say that it is highly unlikely that they would play a major part in any future terrorist attacks. So what use would it be to hand out such treatment to them when we know that there is not much to gain?
If the knowledge claim of the article is indeed true, I think it is deeply regrettable that officials would stoop to such lows to interrogate prisoners. One must not forget and neglect the scientific advancements like the nuero polygraphic test among others, which could provide legal and ethical alternatives to using a gun and drill against helpless prisoners. I agree to the counter argument stressing on the importance of the information such prisoners potentially hold, but the officials and the government as such need to form legislations to prevent such future incidents. Officials to must know where to draw the line while interrogating such prisoners.

Friday, July 31, 2009

Reflections 29 July

What is the difference between a man and an animal? Well 50 minutes of heated, animated and sometimes funny discussion arguments weren't enough for us to come to a conclusion. Personally the only visible difference I see is that humans have a knack for wearing clothes, while animals, well they are of the perception that natural beauty is all that matters! :P
There were many points that my classmates perceived to be major differences. First was the fact that human beings reason, while animals act only instinctively. I strongly disagree with that statement as firstly its fallacious to generalize such a large group of beings and make one categorical statement about them! But nevertheless it’s wrong to say that animals ALWAYS act instinctively. Birds for instance have their entire migration routes planned to save them from the winter frost of various continents. They even fly in various formations to save energy and for aero-dynamical reasons! How can we then say that animal’s don’t reason? It is also wrong to generalize and say that even humans always act with appropriate reasoning. There are countless instances in one's life where emotion is the only ‘reason’ for committing a particular course of action. One just needs to ask Zinedine Zidane about emotions taking the driver’s seat in his life to know what I am talking about.
The second point of difference was that humans have an effective language to communicate while animals don’t. I personally thought that that was ridiculous. Just because we don’t understand animal languages does not mean that they don’t have one. This just epitomized our own shortcomings towards things we don’t comprehend. Language is an essential part of every organism’s life and activity! Animals may be conversing through their barks or their roars and we humans might just never know! We are denying the fact that a certain knowledge stream exists simply because we do not possess it yet!

Our teacher argued that humans have a freewill will animals do not. Again I just could not accept that statement. We can provide counter arguments both ways to prove this statement fallacious. Humans don’t always have a free-will ( just think of an under fire employee wanting to leave everything and go for a vacation, but just cannot due to societal and community constraints) and animals also can possess free will ( a whale cruising aimlessly through the high seas).

Since we could not find any answers, I came to a conclusion that the question itself was an impossible question to answer. To answer such a question one would need to generalize on a large scale basis, and this would only lead to grave inaccuracies! We just cannot generalize and say that all animals don’t reason or all humans never react instinctively without reason. There’s always an exception, and in this case, much more than a sole one! There isn’t much of a natural difference between humans and animals, and if science is to be truly counseled, a man is also a part of the animal category.

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

THE KITE RUNNER K@W

Theory Of Knowledge
Knowledge @ Work

The Kite Runner
The Movie
The Kite Runner is a motion picture set in the Pre-Taliban Afghanistani pandemonium based on Khaled Hussaini's book of the same name. It is emotionally extremely evocative, and the very essence of the film lies in the way even the harshest of scenes are displayed with the subtle touch of innocence. The story is set upon a backdrop of tempestous events, from the demise of the monarchy in Afghanistan through the soviet invasion , the mass departure of "Afghan refugees"Pakistan and the United States, and the treacherous Taliban regime. It elucidates the tale of Amir, a rich boy from Kabul, who is anguished by the guilt of dispensing his childhood friend Hassan, a hazara boy, who, incidentally is the illegitimate son of his Amir's father.
Through out the movie, one's (the knower) perception of Amir as the protagonist is under constant modifications. As a child, Amir, though best friends with Hassan, abandons him when he needs Amir's help the most. The viewer perceives Amir as a rich kid, who only takes undue advantage of Hassan. The intense physical language demonstrated in the film especially through the rape scene has a stinging effect on the viewer's perception of both Amir and Hassan. But as time progresses, and Amir grows up to become a writer in the United States Of America, his character is regenerated to give way to a mature and reasonable young man. "There is a time to be good again": Amir goes back to afghanistan to rescue Hassan;s life. The viewer, thus in the end, leaves the theater with a positive perception of Amir. But can one's wrong deeds be truly undone by right ones. This is the question which each knower can answer through only his or her own perception and reasons.
The Taliban rule in Afghanistan in the film is also perceived as an inhuman and intolerant regime. They reasoned everything with their own perceptions of the Quran and the Islamic religion. The graphic scenes of punishments by the rulers through public stoning ceremonies evoke feelings of extreme anger and sympathy. Since the film is based on actual historical events, one could always argue that the film has a pro-American and anti-Taliban perception towards the history of Afghanistan. But one cannot neglect the cruel atrocities of the Taliban leaders on the locals. The mere thought of molesting children from an orphanage incenses the emotions of the viewer. One can only argue about the ethical nature of the orphanage manager to sacrifice one child to save another ten. After all, we only need to imagine the plight of the sacrificed child to understand the complexities behind such a decision.
The kite Runner is one of the most emotionally evocative movies. But even in a movie with such dramatic events, the climactic scene of the flying kites adds a whole new dimension to the subtlety of the film. Amir runs the kite for Hassan's child, just like Hassan used to when they were young. Amir's dialogue;"For you, a hundred times over", is one of the most soothing yet evocative instances in the film. Even after witnessing all the atrocities, the hardships, the unfortunate incidents, especially with Hassan, the viewer leaves the theater with a gratified feeling.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

tHE LITTLE PRINCE

The Little Prince

Chapter One

This chapter is about the narrator's heartwarming experiences as a child, when he wanted to be a painter. The narrator is nostalgic about his childhood aspiration to be a painter. However he was discouraged from painting by the grown ups, who perceived painting to be a waste of time. They instead asked the narrator to focus on more "important" subjects like math and geography. He was thus asked to concentrate on these subjects and so he did, growing up to become a pilot. The narrator questions the grown up's perception of painting, or rather the lack of it. Grown ups are so robust and mechanic in their lives, that every scope of innovation and creativity is only looked upon by an ignorant eye. The narrator recollects about the day when he tried to draw a boa constrictor. The narrator was fascinated by the fact that boas could swallow entire elephants and then lay dormant for six months. But this fascination was not shared with him by the grown ups, who, understandably and unfortunately, had more essential things in life to worry about. Such is the sense of disconnection and detachment amongst the elders, that they have lost their ability to comprehend and more essentially appreciate, the more common, but magnificent things in life.
Painting is one of the most beauteous forms of expression. Painting is like an escape route for all the emotions which cannot be expressed due to the restraints of spoken language. Paintings, contrary to widespread perception, are simple in nature. One must be free of any preoccupations about life to truly appreciate all forms of paintings. The narrator, as a child had drawn a drawing of a boa constrictor swallowing an elephant. However, no one interpreted the painting as one with a boa, for they all thought that it was just a hat. The shortcomings of perception and language were clearly brought out, as everyone interpreted the same object in different manners. Let down by his early adventures in the profession, the narrator gives up his ambition, but not his dreams, of becoming a painter. Societal pressures forced him to give up his aspirations. It was society;s reasoning that children must pay attention to subjects which would be of "help" in the future and not pursue "useless" hobbies like painting, where one could have no future hopes. It is this overemphasis on academic subjects that is harming children even today. For instance, a simple survey about the age at which children start schooling led to startling observations. In Finland, children are sent to school at the age of seven, while in the rest of the Europe most children start schooling by the age of two! Yet Finland has one of the best student excellence rates in the entire world. This mathematical survey is ample proof that children must be given time, to do what they like, and not be sucked into the realm of world objectives when they are not even 4 years old.
But society for some reason has never been able to get rid of its misconceptions about the worthless nature of extra-curricular activities. For instance, children diagnosed with autism, until recently, were denied admissions to any good schools or colleges. Autism is a learning condition amongst children. But autistic children are found to have better than average creative insights. History tells us that autism or learning disability is no obstacle to success in life. Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin and Vincent Van Gogh, the famous medieval painter, were all known to be autistic. But societal norms pressurize children to kill their innovative and creative instincts and rather focus on the more direct things in life. The narrator craves for someone to share his insights on his drawings, but only meets with failure. There is stark line of mockery in the chapter when the narrator says that he needs to bring himself down to the limited and narrow intellectual level of grown ups to converse with them.

Then I would never talk to that person about boa constrictors, or primeval forests, or stars. I would bring myself down to his level. I would talk to him about bridge, and golf, and politics, and neckties. And the grown-up would be greatly pleased to have met such a sensible man."

Human preoccupations have led to a loss of culture and emotions, which are best embodied by creative forms of language such as painting. Grown ups today take everything at face value, just like they took the boas for the hat. But it would be a confirmation bias to blame the grown ups alone, for when one looks at the drawing of the narrator, it does indeed look like a hat!

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

REFLECTIONS

1. If something is intuitively obvious, must everyone agree about it (is there anything that every1 agrees about)?
2. Could u be wrong in thinking that something is intuitively obvious. (Might you one-day come to see that what u now think is intuitively obvious is in fact a deeply rooted prejudice)
3. Whose intuition should you trust? Are some people’s intuitions are better than others?
1-
Firstly, I have to accept, that I am not quite sure about the exact reference to the term, ‘ intuitively obvious’. After all, how can an intuition be obvious? In fact I perceive that intuition is one fact on the face of this earth that we yet cannot comprehend completely. None of us know the exact reason or cause behind an intuitive feeling. All we can say is that it just happens, “instinctively”! Most of the times we cant even recognize a particular feeling as an instinctive one or not. We find it difficult to express our intuitive feelings, even with all the boundless limitations of language. Thus if something is intuitively obvious, it would mean that thing would be an event which all of us can predict. The only things the human race can agree about are about things over which they have no control. The sun will rise in the east, and so it did, today morning and I had an intuition about the same. Hence if something is intuitively obvious, it must be something over which we have no control. If we have no control over something, than why bother if everyone agrees with it or not, because its still going to happen, whether one likes it, or not!
2-
as discussed, I believe, that the only things that are instinctively obvious are things related to natural phenomenon. No one can be wrong to think if something’s intuitively obvious. This is because of the very nature of intuition. Intuition, unlike a gut feeling, is something that is undeniably true. Therefore no 1 can be wrong to think something is “intuitively” obvious.
3- This one’s interesting. Intuition is a natural quality. The question in itself is incorrect, as intuitions are always true. But maybe what it tries to refer is to the facts that to whose gut feeling does one have a greater inclination to believe in. I perceive that this is a highly subjective question and varies greatly from one individual to another. The world in general would agree that Nostradamus is one person whose gut feelings would be most trustworthy. But again its really upto one’s personal opinion and perception on who to trust and whom to not. Reason plays a minimal part in this discussion and probably through one’s own personal experience, one can judge for himself about whose intuition to trust.

Monday, April 20, 2009

KOW 4- should drugs be legalized.

Rishab Mehta
THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE
KOW 4



13 April, 2009 11:20

The Economics of Legalizing and Regulating Drugs
13 April, 2009 11:20
George Hatjoullis

The drug reform charity Transform (www.tdpf.org.uk) has produced a cost-benefit analysis comparing the continuation of the present drug prohibition strategy with legalization and regulation of now prohibited drugs. The authors conclude that a great deal of money could be saved through legalization and regulation. The economic logic for legalisation and regulation is quite compelling.

A large amount of drug related crime is eliminated overnight, saving costs in the judicial system. Drugs can now be taxed! Legalisation also regularizes the inconsistent treatment of cigarettes and alcohol. Drug production standards can also be raised and maintained. Research into the effects of drugs, and dissemination of this research, is made much easier. So why have successive governments not taken this very obvious route?

One drawback lies in the consequences of unilateral action in a world of drug prohibition. The UK would become a haven for drug tourists from all over the world. Of course, this would bring in more money and have great benefits for the Balance of Payments! However, it does not take too much imagination to conjure up the social problems it might bring in its wake. Imagine the London equivalent of Sun, Sea and Sangria (Sex, Drugs and Rock?). Amsterdam has experimented with a limited version without disastrous consequences, I believe. However, the Transform report seems to have something more ambitious in mind.

The most serious drawback is that drug use would clearly increase. Once again that is good for tax revenue but is this desirable? My reservation comes from my own recent postgraduate studies in psychology. The predisposition to use drugs does not seem to be simply related to the predisposition to addiction once drug use is initiated. There is a risk that increased drug use will bring in its wake a disproportionate increase in addiction. Once again, good for tax revenue but is this desirable? I suggest economic arguments, however compelling, are given less weight until the relation between use and addiction is better understood.




This article is based upon the recent report suggesting that the sale of drugs be legalized in Britain. This would lead to massive economic benefits, says the report. I, as a knower, will try and critically analyze this article by using the various ways of knowing and the areas of knowledge.
The author of the article perceives that legalizing drug trade would only increase overall drug consumption. He comes to this conclusion after a series of psychological observations. Thus we can say that his perception is product of reason and not merely an emotional bias against the use of drugs. But my perception in this case differs completely. This too, is not because of my emotional bias towards promoting drug consumption! A majority of drug takers today are teens. Recent studies have proved that teens usually consume drugs because of the thrill involved in doing so. There is a sort of peer pressure and teens that consume drugs perceive themselves to be the “stylish” ones. But if the government were to legalize drug consumption, the entire ‘thrill’ factor is eliminated. Thus we can reason logically that increased drug consumption as a consequence of legalizing drug trade isn’t really a foregone conclusion. Legalizing drug trade would enable the government to tax the consumption of drugs. This would amount to billions of dollars of revenue every quarter!! In times of recession, such a stimulus would truly be a major boost to the economy. Also, every year, millions of dollars are spent to curb drug trade on the police and the Special Forces. Legalizing drug trade would solve all these problems for the law and order. More importantly, whilst not banning it, the government can still actively discourage drug consumption by spending money on large-scale public education about the harmful effects of drugs.
History too tells us that in the past, developed countries have successfully implemented this idea. Tobacco is even more addictive than certain type of drugs. These countries legalized tobacco usage, but initiated a large scale public health education program about the harmful effects of tobacco. This process was extremely successful and tobacco consumption in these countries is minimal today. Thus we can reason out that legalizing drug trade isn’t as naïve as it seems.
But many knowers will argue about the ethicality of such an audacious piece of legislation. Legalizing drug trade would enable the government. At first, the conservatives (of whom there is no shortage, especially in our country) will probably never accept such an act, even if it is the most obvious course of action. Also, experts may argue, just like George did in the article, that such a step, although may sound feasible in theory, would lead to utter chaos when implemented in practice. Also, if we were to implement this act in isolation, our country would become a major tourist destination, well, of the wrong kind though. The sight of drug dwellers roaming all around the streets of Bombay, doing what they like the most, is enough to tell us about the ethical, and moral feasibility of such an act. I, am of the perception that legalizing drug trade isn’t as crazy as it seems, our country, and for that matter the world, is not prepared for such a drastic step yet! Thus in this paper, I have tried and analyzed both perspectives and sides of the argument and arrived at reasonable and logical conclusion.